The Real Affordability Problem

I bought my first house in the early 1980s, when mortgage rates were near 18%. Buyers today have a harder problem.

I was fortunate to assume a loan at 10%. Those rates hurt, but homes were still priced within reach of what families earned.

Nationally, that’s no longer true. Since 1996, U.S. home prices are up 260%. Household incomes are up 146%. That gap is the real affordability problem.

Rates get most of the blame. They aren’t what worries me most.

The gap opened in two waves. The first was the mid-2000s boom, which only partly corrected after 2008. The second came in 2020, when rates fell to record lows and prices jumped about 30% in two years. Household incomes rose about 10%.

If national home prices had only grown as fast as household incomes since 1996, the median existing home would sell for about $285,000. In September, it sold for $417,500.

Now rates are back up, and prices didn’t come back down.

High rates are painful, but they come and go. High prices tend to stay.

Sources: NAR median existing-home price; U.S. Census Bureau median household income.

Previous
Previous

Doing Less to do More

Next
Next

The Days of Testing the Market Are Over